The X-Files: I wanted to believe
August 8th, 2008
Sorry for the delay between posts, folks. Busy times have come and gone, though there are more on the horizon. I’ve been pretty delinquent in my posting, but I haven’t seen any films in a little while either.
The last film I did make it out to see was The X-Files: I Want To Believe. I must say, after almost two weeks of reflection, I was terribly disappointed by the film.
I need to preface what comes next with this: I was a huge X-Files fan when it was on TV. I watched the show religiously from 93-97 and then watch every episode I could while a college student. Thankfully, this meant I missed most of the crappy seasons. Over the past year, through the magic of DVD, I re-watched the whole series. I rediscovered my love for the show. The early seasons had some great stories, from Flukeman to chupacabra sightings. The conspiracy arc was still a brilliantly devised bit of story-telling. I lamented the fact that Chris Carter and Co. let things go so horribly wrong in the last two seasons. I even re-watched the first X-Files movie. While no great piece of cinema, that movie stands head and shoulders above the latest outing we’ve been treated to.
At least with Fight the Future, the makers realized they needed to break out of the confines of television. What we got was a building blowing up in the first 15 minutes, a helicopter chase through a cornfield and a giant alien spaceship hidden in the ice below Antarctica. Projected onto a giant silver screen, it was a sight to behold. None of those images would have had the same impact on TV in 1998, before the advent of widescreen and HDTV.
Sadly, I Want To Believe never reaches the same scope. As many critics I read noted, this movie seemed to be TV writ large. While some shots try to emulate what Fight the Future, it just doesn’t have the same impact. A row of FBI agents trudging through a snowy meadow is not the same as a huge spacecraft rising from the Antarctic ice. In fact, I felt the shot would have had the same impact were I to see it on a TV screen.
When I first heard that the movie would be a one-off, standalone story with no ties to any story arc from the movie, I was pretty happy. The conspiracy arc became too mired in its own convuluted twists, and the ridiculous super-soldier arc from the last two season was just stupid. That this was going to be a monster-of-the-week story made me hope for something really good, like the Flukeman episode. I thought Carter, with six years removed from the quagmire of Season 9, would go back to the show’s roots and give us a creepy freak of nature as the villain. Sadly this was not the case.
The X-Files: I Want To Believe never had me on the edge of my seat. The villains turned out fairly ordinary, if severely twisted. The big twist is so preposterous, it had me chuckling in my seat.
It’s a shame, really. David Duchovny and Gillian Anderson are still pitch-perfect together as Mulder and Scully. Seeing them together again was like meeting up with two old friends. Amanda Peet, who is either incredibly charming or insanely grating depending on what I see her in, does a decent job as Agent Dakota Whitney (terrible name), a quasi-Mulder disciple at the FBI. I particularly enjoyed Billy Connolly and the psychic paedophile priest. I thought he played the character perfectly. I never got the sense I could trust the character completely, I always had the inkling he was part of the villain’s gallery. I also really enjoyed Callum Keith Rennie turn as a villainous character. Everything he does is performed with cold-blooded ruthlessness, it’s chilling.
So there you have it. A potentially great film filled with actors at the top of their game, brought down by a lacklustre story. I hope that Fox will give Carter another crack at the can but the poor box office performance of the film makes me pessimistic. At least there’s the TV show and the memory of what was.






